Critics Choice April 2024

This month brings you another bumper crop of great reviews from the leading music magazines, quality dailies and online review sites. There’s no doubt about it: Naxos releases and distributes some of the best music and audiovisual albums!

Highly Reviewed Albums of the Month
Naxos 2.110739
Also available on Blu-ray Video
(NBD0155V)
Vallone • Tognocchi • Lebow • Samoilov • Bintner • Frankfurter Opern- und Museumsorchester • Hussain • Schlather
Editor’s Choice | Gramophone

‘“Animated and entertaining, with some good gags” is Richard Wigmore’s verdict of this production of Cimarosa’s opera.’
Gramophone


C. Tetzlaff • Finnish Radio Symphony • Collon
Orchestral Choice | BBC Music Magazine
Recommended | MusicWeb International
Diapason d’Arte | Diapason
Excepcional | Scherzo
★★★★★

‘This compelling release from conductor Nicholas Collon and the Finnish Radio Symphony Orchestra makes clear the evolutionary exuberance of Lutosławski’s creative development.’
BBC Music Magazine

‘Collon and his players deliver invigorating and impeccably riveting performances.’
MusicWeb International

‘Collon…shapes the other two movements with such rhetoric and tension that the multi-faceted music becomes really captivating and yet retains its unity despite all the differentiation.’
Pizzicato ★★★★★

‘…A recording to cherish.’
American Record Guide

Audio Releases
Naxos Releases
Wunderlin • Valentin-Fieguth • Carrel • Ingenpaß • Eisenlohr
Critic’s Choice | American Record Guide

‘Eisenlohr…demonstrates his excellence as a lieder collaborator. His care with details holds your attention as he distills the variety Brahms creates for each strophe, subtly altering the tone or mood of each, often with ingenious harmonizations.’
American Record Guide


Mattix • T. McAllister • Falletta

‘…Falletta in this new, brightly recorded performance of this hugely entertaining score can bear comparison with any.’
Gramophone


R. Richardson • Black Dyke Band • D. and N. Childs

‘You might never hear a euphonium player as technically dazzling as David Childs.’
American Record Guide


Lyric Fest

‘…this fascinating album represents nothing less than a whole new kind of song cycle.’
AllMusic.com ★★★★


Buffalo Philharmonic • Falletta

‘…this release is a delight from beginning to end.’
Fanfare


F. Fernandes • São Paulo Symphony Choir • Goiás Philharmonic • Neil Thomson

‘The excellent performances and sound give this music the best possible presentation.’
American Record Guide


Kayaleh • Blaha
Discos Recomendados | Ritmo

‘…very appealing interpretations that show the two artists as sensitive players.’
Pizzicato ★★★★★


Staatskapelle Halle • Bollon

‘[Bollon] encourages powerful, energetic playing, emphasizing the strong and dazzling timbres, but he also knows how to pull the orchestra back and lead it to a fine chamber music level.’
Pizzicato ★★★★★


J. Baty • Württembergische Philharmonie Reutlingen • Haimor

‘…The musicians prove themselves equal to the unfamiliar pitches and also succeed in confidently presenting the expressive values of the music.’
Pizzicato ★★★★★


A. Meneses • São Paulo Symphony • Karabtchevsky

‘This release, part of Naxos’s Brazilian Music series, is top of the line in every respect, revealing the composer at his most inspired.’
Fanfare


Independent Label Releases (in alphabetical order)
The United States Navy Band • Walden

‘Atmosphere is everything in music like this, and here the US Navy Band has it in spades.’
Fanfare


Fischer-Dieskau • M. Price • Seibel • Städtischer Musikverein zu Düsseldorf • Bavarian State Orchestra • Sawallisch

‘…a magnificent performance under a protective veil of beatific grace.’
Fanfare


Bavarian Radio Symphony • Z. Mehta

‘The present live performance is of a completely different metal, so to speak. With the brass at the peak of their powers, Mehta is the only one to revive Karajan’s grandiose, scathing conception, while translating the “endless horizon” and the “oceans of clouds” with equal sonic splendour.’
Diapason


Stagg • Michelangelo String Quartet • Mentuccia

‘All in all, this is an attractive collection of curiosities presented with affection, commitment and attention to stylistic variety.’
Gramophone


Barton Pine • Royal Scottish National Orchestra • Muñoz
Recording of the Month | MusicWeb International

‘It is an absolute tour de force of violin playing.’
MusicWeb International


Carl Nielsen Quintet
Critic’s Choice | American Record Guide

‘[The Nielsen Quintet’s] playing has a considerable range of volume and nuance. Overall the coordination and presentation here is quite something. The skill and variety in the writing ought to recommend these works to anyone who enjoys the neoclassicism of the 20th Century.’
American Record Guide


Verona Quartet
★★★★

‘The ensemble from the northern Italian city creates performances for these compositions on the basis of a very high technical level, and they specifically bring out their peculiarities.’
Pizzicato ★★★★★

‘…a terrific CD. ’
The WholeNote


Tra Nguyen

‘Tra Nguyen plays with nuance and virtuosity and gets a larger-than-life recording.’
American Record Guide


Konstantin Scherbakov

‘…do not miss these wonderfully imaginative studies based on Chopin’s original etudes.’
American Record Guide


Mosca • Goy

‘This is splendid entertainment.’
American Record Guide


Lively • Freiburg Vocal Ensemble • South West German Radio Symphony Orchestra • Baden-Baden • Gielen

‘David Lively’s playing is extremely virtuosic …this brilliant and exciting recording easily takes its place at the top of the catalogue.’
Pizzicato ★★★★★


Thiele • Mio Tamayama • Archos Quartet

‘…it would be hard pressed to match the rhythmic vitality, transparency and warmth of the Archos Quartet.’
The Strad

‘…This music, heard here in world première recordings, is a delight, and I would even go so far as to call it revelatory.’
Fanfare


Utah Symphony • Abravanel

‘Conductor, orchestra and recordists conspire to achieve a Tchaikovsky Second that makes perfect musical sense, the sound admirably transparent, the finale strong and forceful (such marvellous brass).’
Gramophone

Audiovisual Releases
Naxos Releases
Naxos 2.110757
Also available on Blu-ray Video
(NBD0169V)
Dasch • Kronthaler • Reinhardt • Oliemans • Poort • Atsma • Melles • Chorus of Dutch National Opera • Netherlands Philharmonic Orchestra • Metropole Orchestra • Dutch String Collective • Letonja • Loy

‘It’s all tender, touching and nostalgic.’
Opera


Naxos 2.110766–67
Also available on Blu-ray Video
(NBD0178-79V)
Stober • Vogt • Ya-Chung Huang • Jekal • Reuter • Pesendorfer • Deutsche Oper Berlin Chorus and Orchestra • Fiore • Wieler • Morabito • Viebrock

‘Musical satisfaction kicks in immediately, with the conductor John Fiore steaming into the Prelude, rousingly played by the orchestra… Each act is expertly paced; the chorus is on generous form… Reuter’s Sachs is key to the staging, strong in baritonal depth and magnetically watchable.’
Opera


Independent Releases (in alphabetical order)
BelAir Classiques BAC224
Also available on Blu-ray Video
(BAC524)
Brownlee • Fuchs • Teitgen • Mauillon • Pierro • Vidal • Mechelen • Bounazou • Bignagni Lesca • Les Musiciens du Louvre • Choeurs l’Opera National de Paris • Minkowski • Pelly

‘This is a truly remarkable achievement for Brownlee and it is his finest work to date… [Fuchs] delivers a knock-out performance.’
MusicWeb International


C Major 764308
Also available on Blu-ray Video
(764404)
Flórez • Mimica • Spyres • Jicia • Abrahamyan • Iniesta • Brito • Merli • Baldinotti • Bologna Teatro Comunale Chorus and Orchestra • Mariotti • Michieletto
Discos Recomendados | Ritmo

‘…this Rossinian La Donna del Lago sweeps us off our feet thanks to a top-flight cast.’
Diapason


Bowman • Cotrubas • Appelgren • Lott • Glyndebourne Chorus • London Philharmonic Orchestra • Haitink • Hall
Discos Recomendados | Ritmo
Nominee for Recording of the Year | MusicWeb International

‘…a superbly realised production of a stunning beautiful work which should be in every collection.’
MusicWeb International

‘This is a wonderful performance… gloriously sung by a perfect ensemble cast. Haitink’s leadership in Glyndebourne brings some remarkably silken and deft playing from the LPO…’
Fanfare

AudioBooks
David Timson
Earphones Award | AudioFile

‘Timson keeps all the major and a great many minor characters alive and individualized, maintaining listeners’ engagement all the way to the end.’
AudioFile



View all Features »